Uzbekistan: Ensure Fair Appeal for Human Rights Defender
Consider Whether Charges Politically Motivated
November 20, 2009
Related Materials:
Uzbekistan: Stop Harassing Activists
There is a well documented practice of the government of Uzbekistan, using trumped-up criminal charges against human rights defenders, and Mukhtarov’s conviction fits that pattern.He should never have been put on trial in a criminal court in the first place.
Holly Cartner, Europe and Central Asia director
(New York) – Uzbek authorities should ensure that an appeal hearing that began today for a human rights advocate is fair and independent, Human Rights Watch said. The activist, Farkhad Mukhtarov, was convicted of criminal charges in a trial that appeared to have been politically motivated, and he was denied the right to defend himself fully, Human Rights Watch said.
Mukhtarov is a long-term member of the Human Rights Alliance of Uzbekistan. He was convicted of fraud and bribery on October 2, 2009 by the Yunusabad District Criminal Court and sentenced to five years in prison. During the trial, and again today at the appeals hearing, plaintiffs withdrew their claims against Mukhtarov, effectively removing the basis for the criminal conviction.
“There is a well documented practice of the government of Uzbekistan, using trumped-up criminal charges against human rights defenders, and Mukhtarov’s conviction fits that pattern,” said Holly Cartner, Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “He should never have been put on trial in a criminal court in the first place.”
Mukhtarov was arrested on July 17, 2009, on the basis of complaints made by Shoira Sadykbekova, M. Karimova, A. Eshanov, and V. Bikbulatova. Sadykbekova accused Mukhtarov of misappropriating 5 million som (roughly US $3320) she had allegedly given him to represent her interests in civil proceedings in 2006, saying he had used this money to bribe the judge. The other plaintiffs accused him of misappropriating large sums of money allegedly given to him as deposits to buy apartments from him. He was charged with fraud (under article 168-3 of the Uzbek Criminal Code) and bribery (under article 28-211-2) by the Yunusabad District prosecutor’s office.
Mukhtarov says he is innocent and his human rights colleagues consider the allegations politically motivated in retaliation for his human rights activities.
Members of the Human Rights Alliance who attended the trial, which began on September 7, 2009, told Human Rights Watch that Mukhtarov did not get a fair hearing and that the trial was riddled with procedural violations. They said he was ill-treated while in custody, although he reportedly did not say so during the trial.
They said that the judge, R. R. Bakieva, regularly interrupted Mukhtarov and his lawyers and on at least on one occasion, threatened to expel him from the courtroom and continue the trial without him after he whispered to his lawyer.
Judge Bakieva reportedly refused petitions from Mukhtarov’s lawyers, including a request to present defense witnesses. Two of them reportedly intended to testify that their signatures had been falsified on a statement Sadykbekova had given to the court. The judge also refused to admit into evidence an audio recording in which Sadykbekova reportedly was unable to answer questions posed by Mukhtarov about when she had given him money and how much. The judge also reportedly refused to give Mukhtarov’s lawyers time to prepare for the closing statement.
The observers said the prosecutor attended only two of the trial’s numerous sessions and that some sessions took place without an Uzbek-Russian interpreter, though one of Mukhtarov’s lawyers does not speak Uzbek.
Moreover, on September 25, Bikbulatova testified in court that she had no claims against him. In response, Judge Bakieva reportedly asked Bikbulatova three times whether she was sure and then suggested she might want to sue Mukhtarov for moral damages. Bikbulatova refused.
On September 30, two of the other plaintiffs, Karimova and Eshanov, wrote statements in which they said they have no claims against Mukhtarov. On October 2, when they were to submit these statements to the court, Eshanov decided not to, but then changed his mind. Judge Bakieva refused to accept his statement.
Eshkanov submitted his statement at the hearing today at the Tashkent City Criminal Court. Court documents and information shared with Human Rights Watch by Alliance members who attended the trial show that Sadykbekov presented no evidence to substantiate her claims, nor did any of the prosecution’s witnesses provide corroboration. At most, under Uzbek law, Sadykbekova’s allegations should have given rise to civil, not criminal, charges.
On October 2, Mukhtarov’s wife, Surayo, took the amount of money Mukhtarov was accused of owing Sadykbekova to the sentencing hearing to give her as a goodwill gesture, but the judge confiscated the money.
The appeals court today called a recess to consider both Eshanov’s statement and a complaint from Sadykbekova over confiscation of the money. The appeals hearing is scheduled to continue on December 3.
29 Responses to “Mukhtarov did not get a fair hearing…”
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
This is some great material. It took me quite some time to seek out this web site but it surely was worth the time. I noticed this article was buried in bing rather than the main spot. This excellent website provides extensive first-rate material and yes it doesnt deserve to be burried on the internet prefer that. In addition I am going to save this web publication to my listing of favorites.
Some truly wonderful posts on this web site , thankyou for contribution.
Good day! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my previous room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this post to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!
I’ve said that least 1418609 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean
Thank you for your thoughtful post!
yeah bookmaking this wasnt a high risk determination outstanding post! .
I intended to create you this very small observation so as to thank you so much the moment again just for the pretty tricks you have featured above. It was so unbelievably open-handed of people like you to make extensively just what a few individuals could have sold for an e book to end up making some money for their own end, principally given that you could have tried it in the event you wanted. The principles additionally acted to be a fantastic way to know that other people online have a similar zeal much like mine to learn more with regard to this condition. I’m sure there are some more pleasurable situations in the future for people who start reading your blog post.
I precisely needed to say thanks yet again. I’m not certain the things I might have done without the entire points shown by you regarding my subject matter. It was a real difficult matter in my view, however , coming across the very specialised technique you processed it forced me to jump for contentment. I will be thankful for your assistance and thus sincerely hope you are aware of an amazing job you have been carrying out instructing others using your webblog. I am sure you have never got to know any of us.
I truly appreciate this post. I have been looking everywhere for this! Thank goodness I identified it on Bing. You might have produced my day! Thx once more!
Yeah bookmaking this wasn’t a speculative decision great post!
You made some decent factors there. I appeared on the internet for the problem and located most individuals will go along with together with your website.
Hey there, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, terrific blog!
Certainly one of many challenges which individuals starting a brand new on-line firm face is that of acquiring visitors to their web site.
Thank you so much, it has been bothering me that I could not figure this out. Thanks again!
Thanks for sharing, I found this story while googling for song lyrics, useful comments and good points made.
I’m still learning from you, but I’m making my way to the top as well. I definitely liked reading everything that is written on your site.Keep the information coming. I liked it!
AutoPreisService.de ist ein bekanntes Portal für den hochrabattierten Neuwagenkauf für Privatkäufer und gewerbliche Kunden.
Have you ever considered creating an e-book or guest authoring on other blogs? I have a blog based upon on the same subjects you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my readers would enjoy your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an e-mail.
i like your article
I wanted to thanks for this nice read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it I’ve you bookmarked to check out new stuff you submit
Very good website! I truly enjoy how it’s simple on my eyes and the data are effectively written. I am wondering how I could be notified whenever a new post has been created. I have subscribed to your feed which need to do the trick! Have a great day!
Fantastic website. Plenty of useful information here. I’m sending it to several friends ans also sharing in delicious. And of course, thanks for your sweat!
I wished to thank you for this nice learn!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it I’ve you bookmarked to check out new stuff you publish
Keep up the superb work , I read few posts on this site and I believe that your website is real interesting and has got circles of superb information.
Many thanks for posting this, It’s just what I was researching for on bing. I’d rather a lot comparatively hear opinions from a person, slightly than an organization web web page, that’s why I like blogs so significantly. Many thanks!
This one is an inspiration personally to uncover out far more related to this subject. I must confess your knowledge prolonged my sentiments as well as I am going to proper now take your feed to remain updated on every coming blog posts you may possibly create. You’re worthy of thanks for a job completely done!
This one is an inspiration personally to uncover out much more related to this subject. I have to confess your knowledge extended my sentiments in addition to I’m going to proper now take your feed to remain up to date on each coming weblog posts you would possibly presumably create. You’re worthy of thanks for a job perfectly carried out!
I’m still learning from you, however I’m enhancing myself. I certainly love studying everything that’s written in your blog.Preserve the tales coming. I liked it!
I needed to thanks for this nice learn!! I definitely having fun with each little little bit of it I’ve you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post